diff --git a/token_bot/controller/alerts.py b/token_bot/controller/alerts.py
index f032351..1626e55 100644
--- a/token_bot/controller/alerts.py
+++ b/token_bot/controller/alerts.py
@@ -25,16 +25,19 @@ class AlertsController:
             return Alert.from_str(alert)
         return alert
 
-    async def add_user(self, user: int | User, alert: str | Alert) -> None:
-        user = self._user_to_obj(user)
+    async def get_users(self, alert: str | Alert) -> List[User]:
         alert = self._alert_to_obj(alert)
+        await alert.get(self.table, consistent=True)
+        return alert.users
+
+    async def add_user(self, alert: str | Alert, user: int | User):
+        alert = self._alert_to_obj(alert)
+        user = self._user_to_obj(user)
         await alert.add_user(self.table, user)
 
-    async def delete_user(self, user: int | User, alert: str | Alert):
-        user = self._user_to_obj(user)
+    async def remove_user(self, alert: str | Alert, user: int | User):
         alert = self._alert_to_obj(alert)
+        user = self._user_to_obj(user)
         await alert.remove_user(self.table, user)
 
-    async def get_users(self, alert: str | Alert, consistent: bool = False) -> List[User]:
-        alert = self._alert_to_obj(alert)
-        return await alert.get_users(self.table, consistent=consistent )
+
diff --git a/token_bot/controller/users.py b/token_bot/controller/users.py
index 35733e2..4057ced 100644
--- a/token_bot/controller/users.py
+++ b/token_bot/controller/users.py
@@ -60,3 +60,11 @@ class UsersController:
         await user.get(self.table)
         user.subscribed_alerts.append(alert)
         await user.put(self.table)
+
+    async def remove_alert(self, user: int | User, alert: str | Alert) -> None:
+        user = self._user_to_obj(user)
+        alert = self._alert_to_obj(alert)
+        await user.get(self.table)
+        user.subscribed_alerts.remove(alert)
+        await user.put(self.table)
+
diff --git a/token_bot/persistant_database/alert_schema.py b/token_bot/persistant_database/alert_schema.py
index 9487df1..adb3de9 100644
--- a/token_bot/persistant_database/alert_schema.py
+++ b/token_bot/persistant_database/alert_schema.py
@@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ class Alert:
         self.region: Region = region
         self.price: int = price
         self._loaded: bool = False
-        self._users: List[pdb.User] = []
+        self.users: List[pdb.User] = []
 
     @classmethod
     def from_item(cls, primary_key: int, sort_key: str, users: List[int]) -> 'Alert':
@@ -82,18 +82,15 @@ class Alert:
             await self.get(table, consistent=consistent)
 
     async def _append_user(self, table: Table, user: pdb.User) -> None:
-        self._users.append(user)
+        self.users.append(user)
         await self.put(table)
 
     async def _remove_user(self, table: Table, user: pdb.User) -> None:
-        update_expression = F("users").delete({user.user_id})
-        await table.update_item(
-            key=self.key,
-            update_expression=update_expression
-        )
+        self.users.remove(user)
+        await self.put(table)
 
     async def put(self, table: Table) -> None:
-        user_ids = [str(user.user_id) for user in self._users]
+        user_ids = [str(user.user_id) for user in self.users]
         await table.put_item(
             item={
                 self.primary_key_name: self.primary_key,
@@ -110,23 +107,23 @@ class Alert:
             )
         except ItemNotFound:
             return False
-        self._users = [pdb.User(int(user_id)) for user_id in response['users']]
+        self.users = [pdb.User(int(user_id)) for user_id in response['users']]
         self._loaded = True
         return True
 
     async def get_users(self, table: Table, consistent: bool = False) -> List[pdb.User]:
         await self._lazy_load(table, consistent=consistent)
 
-        return self._users
+        return self.users
 
     async def add_user(self, table: Table, user: pdb.User, consistent: bool = False) -> None:
         await self._lazy_load(table, consistent=consistent)
 
-        if user not in self._users:
+        if user not in self.users:
             await self._append_user(table=table, user=user)
 
     async def remove_user(self, table: Table, user: pdb.User, consistent: bool = True) -> None:
         await self._lazy_load(table, consistent=consistent)
 
-        if user in self._users:
+        if user in self.users:
             await self._remove_user(table=table, user=user)
diff --git a/token_bot/persistant_database/user_schema.py b/token_bot/persistant_database/user_schema.py
index 70b51b5..80399ee 100644
--- a/token_bot/persistant_database/user_schema.py
+++ b/token_bot/persistant_database/user_schema.py
@@ -59,9 +59,6 @@ class User:
     async def delete(self, table: Table) -> None:
         if not self._loaded:
             await self._lazy_load(table, consistent=True)
-        if self.subscribed_alerts:
-            for alert in self.subscribed_alerts:
-                await alert.remove_user(table, self)
         await table.delete_item(
             key={self.primary_key_name: self.primary_key},
         )
@@ -80,3 +77,15 @@ class User:
             self.subscribed_alerts.append(pdb.Alert.from_str(string_trinity))
         self.region = Region(response['region'])
         return True
+
+    async def add_alert(self, table: Table, alert: 'pdb.Alert', consistent: bool = False) -> None:
+        await self._lazy_load(table, consistent=consistent)
+        if alert not in self.subscribed_alerts:
+            self.subscribed_alerts.append(alert)
+            await self.put(table)
+
+    async def remove_alert(self, table: Table, alert: 'pdb.Alert', consistent: bool = True) -> None:
+        await self._lazy_load(table, consistent=consistent)
+        if alert in self.subscribed_alerts:
+            self.subscribed_alerts.remove(alert)
+            await self.put(table)